E. McClung Fleming

Artifact Study: A Proposed Model

pointe shoe
Fleming provides rigorous and systematic categories which aid in the examination of objects. He propsoses that all the significant characteristics of an object can be explored and and related by looking at five basic properties: History, Material, Construction, Design, and Function. Fleming advises that these five properties be examined by applying four different operations: Indentification, Evaluation, Cultural Analysis, and Interpretation. However, I believe these areas are covered more effectively by the other theorists I have selected.

Property

Description

History

This property is not extremely illuminating at this point. Undoubtedly, once I have done more research it may prove more useful. The historical information that Fleming seems interested in here applies to the area of provenance and unique objects. It is less useful when approaching generic objects like shoes, or pointe shoes, in particular.

Material

The basic components used in the manufacture of pointe shoes are satin, paper and hessian, which are used to form the block, and the leather sole. Two layers of canvas line the interior of the shoe. Satin encases the exterior of the shoe and is usually flesh-coloured. Hessian and paper form the “block” or hard toe of the shoe. The leather used to form the sole or shank comes in varying degrees of stiffness but, overall, is quite rigid.

Construction

The block, or hard toe of the shoe, is usually formed by hand, building it up layer by layer using hessian triangles, paper and glue. The basis of the glue is commonly a simple flour and water paste. After the block is formed, the shoe is then stitched, joining the leather sole to the satin casing or upper. The insole is then inserted into the shoe. At this stage, the glue in the block is not yet dry and hard. This allows the maker to fashion and shape the block with the aid of a smooth hammer, creating the “platform” or flattened tip of the shoe. The shoe is then placed into an "oven" overnight where it bakes and hardens.

Design

While a fine fabric, the satin that makes up the outer casing of the pointe shoe tends to be unadorned and flesh-coloured. The ribbons, which are wrapped around the top of the foot and ankle are also of satin. This decorative aspect fulfills two functions (discussed in the next section).

Function

The stiff block encompassing the toe area of the shoe has a flattened tip or “platform,” which allows the dancer to shift her weight to the tips of her toes, en pointe, and balance more easily. Ribbons, which the dancer sews on herself, hold the shoe in place as well as add stability to the ankle. The leather shank is quite stiff and lends stability to the foot as well. However, the shank is “broken” by some dancers – by strategically breaking the shank, the foot is able to bend more easily, lending a more attractive arch to the foot. It is questionable whether satin is the best fabric for pointe shoes. It is quite delicate and tends to fray at the toe-tip where the greatest degree of stress occurs. However, it is smooth and a little slippery, which allows for greater ease in turning and shifting weight. The colour of the shoe, when combined with pink tights (another common item of clothing for dancers), makes the leg look long and continuous, effacing the foot.

 

Fleming
McCracken
Dupont
Swan & Manning